10 Most Unique Christian Gifts

Are you looking for a unique Christian gift for a loved one?

Do you agree that Christians gifts are better than regular girls?

Are you looking for something thoughtful that also serves as a reminder that God is there?

If the answer is yes— you’re in the right place then!

In a hurry? Here's The Dads CHOICE CHRISTIAN GIFT!

cap icon
Carved Felt Bible Tote »

The Carved Felt Bible Tote by Bridawn is an all-around great gift for any religious friend or family member!

GO CHECK PRICE »

In these trying times, one of the best things you can give a friend or family is a reminder of their faith.

Whether it’s their birthday or a holiday is staring at you from right around the corner, gifts of faith are always the way to go for a Christian friend or family member.

In this review, we cover ten of the most unique Christian gifts out there today.

We took special note of things like utility and quality, so whatever gift you choose lasts for a long time even with daily use. Each gift was hand-picked by our dads based on uniqueness, availability, price, and the reminder of faith.

We came into this review knowing that one of the most important aspects of Christian gifts is to have a reminder of faith showing proudly, not hidden, or locked behind a book cover. When comparing each gift, we took into consideration everything from appearance to usefulness.

We know how difficult it can be to find a unique gift that isn’t a bible, so we searched high and low for every pick. We’ve also included the specs and any applicable style options for each of the gifts we recommend.

Top 10 Unique Christian Gifts

We searched high and low for each gift, so we feel proud to share the best selection of unique Christian gifts. We then provide a final rating for each choice based on our extensive knowledge of the gift market, and our findings are compiled into an informative table and in-depth reviews.

Additionally, we have included a list of frequently asked questions that will help you smooth out any wrinkles before you dive into buying a unique Christian gift.

DAD’S #1 CHOICE
419zgUPAKYL

1. Carved Felt Bible Tote

The Carved Felt Bible Tote by Bridawn is an all-around great gift for any religious friend or family member.  Made of thick felt, this tote is large enough to carry a bible and any other items you bring with you to bible study or church like a phone, laptop, tablet, pens, or a notebook. The premium polyurethane leather handles are comfortable and close with a magnetic snap. It can also be used as a handbag, makeup bag, or multi-purpose tote.

Read Our Full Review
9.9
The DadsAgree score (out of 10) is generated using a weighted algorithm based on team reviews, amazon reviews & overall company trustworthiness.
GO CHECK PRICE »
Best Christian Valentine Gifts

1

2. Color Changing Magic Mug

Whether your loved one likes coffee or tea, this “Magic” Coffee Mug from MagicalStoreGifts on Etsy is a great way to make their mornings. 

Read Our Full Review
Best Christian Gift For Girls
1

3. 52 Week Scripture, Devotional, and Guided Prayer Journal for Women

Any woman can benefit from tapping into their faith each week outside of Sunday prayer. This prayer journal will last your giftee an entire year with 52 sections for each week. Inside each week is a scripture, a reflection section, two pages to journal, and a tracker to write down prayers and those that have been answered.

Read Our Full Review
Best Christian Graduation Gift
1

4. Proverbs 3:5 Engraved Gift Pen

Inkstone has plenty of engraved gift pens, but this is their most popular one. The casing is a slick black with copper accents. It comes in a satin-lined presentation gift box so you can easily wrap it with a bow or gift it as-is. 

Read Our Full Review
Best Christian Wedding Gift
51nSbnLrFrL

5. Bamboo Cutting Board

If you’re gifting for a chef or an enthusiastic home cook, consider the Bamboo Cutting Board by Christian Art Gifts. The great thing about this cutting board is that it can be used decoratively (think charcuterie) or as a functional cutting board while they’re preparing meats or vegetables.

Read Our Full Review
Best Christian Housewarming Gift
518YAZicloL

6. Matthew 19:26 Wall Plaque

A simple gift yet one that speaks a thousand words is this Matthew 19:26 Wall Plaque. Also made by Christian Art Gifts, this home decor addition gives your loved one a friendly reminder of strength each day. 

Read Our Full Review
Best Christian Gift For Teens
51dv+URHUoL

7. God’s Path Compass

The sentiment behind this God’s Path Compass goes without saying. Although we all have compasses on our phones nowadays, this compass points toward God instead of North, reminding your giftee what they’re always working towards. Of course, this can be used as an actual compass when hiking or camping.

Read Our Full Review
Best Value
51qscAJoD9L

8. 12 Pack Christian Guitar Picks

These guitar picks are one of our favorite choices because they’re a great choice for a guitar player in your life, especially if you know someone who plays during Sunday service. They can also be a great addition for any religious friend or family member who collects guitar picks or be put inside a wallet as a constant reminder.

Read Our Full Review
Best Christian Friendship Gift

41anmVvL24L

9. Christian Wood Pattern 12 oz Tumbler

There are lots of Christian mugs out there, but the downfall is that regardless of the coffee, tea, or hot chocolate that’s put in it, it will get cold quickly. This patterned wood tumbler from Nui Living is a great alternative.

Read Our Full Review
Best Christian Gift For Men

Blessed is the Man Who Trusts in the Lord Fathers Day Hammer image 0

10. Blessed is the Man Decal Hammer

You came here looking for something unique, and here’s one uncommon gift. This Blessed is the Man Hammer from ClothedinChristCo on Etsy is an excellent gift for the handyman or DIY-er in your life.

Read Our Full Review

Carved Felt Bible Tote

9.9
DAD’S #1 CHOICE
  • Available in six colors: beige, light/dark grey, pink, purple, and red
  • Quotations: Six different religious quotations
  • Snap: Magnetic snap
  • Handle: Leather handle
  • Material: Thick felt material
  • Size: 13.8” x 9.4” x 3.7”

The Carved Felt Bible Tote by Bridawn is an all-around great gift for any religious friend or family member.

Made of thick felt, this tote is large enough to carry a bible and any other items you bring with you to bible study or church like a phone, laptop, tablet, pens, or a notebook. The premium polyurethane leather handles are comfortable and close with a magnetic snap. It can also be used as a handbag, makeup bag, or multi-purpose tote.

Each of the six colors offered has a different religious quotation carved into the front, along with a cross positioned prominently near the handle. The quotations include blurbs like, “I know the plans I have for you” and “Be strong and courageous.”

DADS LIKEY

  • Affordable and thoughtful
  • Soft felt material yet sturdy handles
  • Six different colors
  • Different quotations on each tote
  • Large enough to carry more than just a bible

DADS NO LIKEY

  • No internal pockets, just one large pocket
  • Hand washing recommended

Color Changing Magic Mug

9.8
Best Christian Valentine Gifts
  • Making: Handmade
  • Exterior: Black exterior, tan when revealed

Whether your loved one likes coffee or tea, this “Magic” Coffee Mug from MagicalStoreGifts on Etsy is a great way to make their mornings.

When filled with nothing or a cold liquid, the mug is purely black with “faith” written vertically on the side. After putting hot liquid in the mug, the black will slowly fade away and reveal a tan exterior with Isaiah 41:10. It states, “Fear not, for I am with you; Be not dismayed, for I am your God; I will strengthen you, Yes I will help you; I will uphold you with my righteous right hand.”

The verse is surrounded by a simplistic gold border and pink flowers.

DADS LIKEY

  • Handmade, so you can feel proud of the gift you’ve chosen
  • Give them a surprise in the mornings
  • Great for coffee, tea, hot chocolate, or any hot beverage your loved one enjoys
  • Comes in an attractive, simplistic box

DADS NO LIKEY

  • None

52 Week Scripture, Devotional, and Guided Prayer Journal for Women

9.8
Best Christian Gift For Girls
  • Pages: 231 pages
  • Size: 8x10”

Any woman can benefit from tapping into their faith each week outside of Sunday prayer.

This prayer journal will last your giftee an entire year with 52 sections for each week. Inside each week is a scripture, a reflection section, two pages to journal, and a tracker to write down prayers and those that have been answered.

There are original illustrations on each page by author and artist Shannon Roberts. The verses are organized thematically:

  • Crawl up and down the stairs.
  • Provision & Faithfulness
  • God’s Love
  • Adversity & Trials
  • Awe & Sovereignty
  • Strength Through Faith
  • Fear
  • Grace & Forgiveness

There is a spiral-bound version of the same journal available for easier flipping, but that one is double the price. If your loved one is left-handed, you probably want to stick with the original version.

DADS LIKEY

  • A gift that lasts for an entire year
  • Themed verses
  • Original illustrations by the author on each page
  • 8x10 large size

DADS NO LIKEY

  • The Spiral-bound version is expensive

Proverbs 3:5 Engraved Gift Pen

9.7
Best Christian Graduation Gift
  • Compatibility: Compatible with G2 “Parker-ink” cartridges
  • Ink: Black ink
  • Closure: Twist closure
  • Tip: Ballpoint tip
  • Weight: 45 grams
  • Size: 5.6” long

Inkstone has plenty of engraved gift pens, but this is their most popular one. The casing is a slick black with copper accents. It comes in a satin-lined presentation gift box so you can easily wrap it with a bow or gift it as-is.

The top of the pen is engraved with “Proverbs 3:5” and the shaft of the pen states, “Trust in the Lord with all your heart, and lean not on your own understanding.” This is a great gift for a writer, pastor, or anyone who spends a lot of time with a pen in their hand. It’s a reminder to trust in God whenever they’re in the midst of a problem at work.

The ink is compatible with G2 parker-ink cartridges, so you don’t have to worry about them tossing the pen at the end of its life, and can give them refills along with the pen. The original ink does not perform as well as the cartridges, but that’s an easy fix. The quality is guaranteed as well. This pen is smooth and steady with a ballpoint tip and ink. It closes with a twist.

DADS LIKEY

  • Already comes in a satin-lined gift box
  • Inkstone has other identical pens with different verses depending on your preference
  • Ballpoint ink and tip writes flawlessly
  • Ink is replaceable
  • High-quality casing

DADS NO LIKEY

  • A little expensive for a pen
  • Original ink does not work as well as the replacement cartridges since it sits stagnant for a while before getting shipped.

Bamboo Cutting Board

9.7
Best Christian Wedding Gift
  • Engraved: Laser-engraved
  • Making: 100% natural bamboo
  • Small:: 7.5” x 13.75”
  • Large:: 15.4” x 12”

If you’re gifting for a chef or an enthusiastic home cook, consider the Bamboo Cutting Board by Christian Art Gifts. The great thing about this cutting board is that it can be used decoratively (think charcuterie) or as a functional cutting board while they’re preparing meats or vegetables.

The bamboo is 100% natural and is laser-engraved with a unique saying. There are three small cutting boards with the following sayings on each:

  • “Bless the food before us, the family beside us, and the love between us. Amen.”
  • “Blessed beyond measure”
  • “Gather here”

They offer one large cutting board that says, “Give us this day our daily bread.” The cutting board is a great gift for anyone with a passion for cooking, and they can be reminded of their faith even when going through their daily routine.

The only downside is that hand washing is recommended, so they won’t be able to throw it in the dishwasher on a whim.

DADS LIKEY

  • 100% natural
  • Four different religious engravings
  • Can be used decoratively or functionally

DADS NO LIKEY

  • Needs to be hand washed

Matthew 19:26 Wall Plaque

9.6
Best Christian Housewarming Gift
  • Design: Chalkboard design
  • Frame: Wood frame with glass
  • Hook: Hanging hooks
  • Size: 10.4” x 0.6” x 11.5”

A simple gift yet one that speaks a thousand words is this Matthew 19:26 Wall Plaque. Also made by Christian Art Gifts, this home decor addition gives your loved one a friendly reminder of strength each day.

Matthew 19:26 states, “With God all things are possible.” The letters are drawn in a lovely, white calligraphy fashion with a black chalkboard background to give it a rustic, handmade appearance. The wooden frame has a hook on the back for hanging.

DADS LIKEY

  • Rustic design
  • Easy hanging

DADS NO LIKEY

  • None

God’s Path Compass

9.6
Best Christian Gift For Teens
  • Material: Premium brass housing and chain
  • Scripture: Engraved scripture

The sentiment behind this God’s Path Compass goes without saying. Although we all have compasses on our phones nowadays, this compass points toward God instead of North, reminding your giftee what they’re always working towards. Of course, this can be used as an actual compass when hiking or camping.

It’s housed in premium brass and comes in a wooden keepsake box lined with blue velvet. The engraved verse is Psalms 32:8, “I will guide you along the best pathway for your life. I will advise you and watch over you.”

Gift packaging and a greeting card are included, so you can skip needing to buy gift wrap and write out your own personalized message. This compass is great for any occasion but is frequently purchased for graduations and baptisms.

DADS LIKEY

  • High-quality brass material
  • Motivational psalm
  • Already comes with gift packaging and card

DADS NO LIKEY

  • Pricey

12 Pack Christian Guitar Picks

9.5
Best Value
  • Collections: Five themed collections
  • Pack: 12 pack
  • Durablity: Durable celluloid construction
  • Design: Double-sided design

These guitar picks are one of our favorite choices because they’re a great choice for a guitar player in your life, especially if you know someone who plays during Sunday service. They can also be a great addition for any religious friend or family member who collects guitar picks or be put inside a wallet as a constant reminder.

There are five different collections to choose from with different themes, such as:

  • God is Love
  • In Christ Alone
  • Jesus Has Risen
  • Psalms

The NewEights Store is responsive to customer feedback, so if you’re unhappy at all with your gift purchase, you have a 60-day money-back guarantee, although we don’t think you’ll have to use it.

DADS LIKEY

  • 60-day money-back guarantee if you’re unhappy
  • Made from durable celluloid
  • Can be used for a variety of activities
  • Affordable
  • Can be gifted to multiple people

DADS NO LIKEY

  • None

Christian Wood Pattern 12 oz Tumbler

9.5
Best Christian Friendship Gift
  • Material: Insulated stainless steel
  • Capacity: 12-ounce capacity
  • Lid: Spill-proof clear lid
  • Size: 5.2” x 4.3” x 3.8”

There are lots of Christian mugs out there, but the downfall is that regardless of the coffee, tea, or hot chocolate that’s put in it, it will get cold quickly. This patterned wood tumbler from Nui Living is a great alternative.

The insulated stainless steel interior keeps drinks cold for over nine hours or hot for over three hours and is great for traveling. The exterior has an authentic wood pattern with a metallic design that features a cross equaling love. It can be used for a variety of beverages, alcoholic and non-alcoholic.

 

DADS LIKEY

  • Insulated design keeps cold drinks cold, and hot drinks hot for hours
  • Simplistic yet meaningful design
  • The spill-proof lid prevents accidents

DADS NO LIKEY

  • 12-ounce capacity is on the smaller side and will need to be refilled often if it’s used throughout the day

Blessed is the Man Decal Hammer

9.4
Best Christian Gift For Men
  • Weight: 16 oz. hammer

You came here looking for something unique, and here’s one uncommon gift. This Blessed is the Man Hammer from ClothedinChristCo on Etsy is an excellent gift for the handyman or DIY-er in your life.

The 16-ounce stainless steel hammer has a wooden handle with a decal that states, “Blessed is the man who trusts in the Lord” from Jeremiah 17:7. This is a great keepsake to hang on the wall or to be used for daily projects.

DADS LIKEY

  • Everyday use item
  • ClothedinChristCo is a Christian-based company

DADS NO LIKEY

  • The verse is a decal, not engraved, so it can peel off with constant use

Frequently Asked Questions

If you’ve decided to buy a religious loved one a Christian gift, the most important thing you can do is consider their hobbies. If someone likes writing, then you might consider the engraved gift pen, or if they like playing the guitar, then the guitar picks are a great choice as well. Pick something that will give them a daily reminder of their faith as they go through their routine.

There are many verses in the Bible that talk about gifts, whether physical or spiritual. Our favorite verse is 1 Peter 4:10, “As each has received a gift, use it to serve one another, as good stewards of God's varied grace.” 

Using your religious beliefs to serve another is a gift in itself, but an example of unique Christian gifts that can be used to serve others include the Bamboo Cutting Board or the Decal Hammer.

Clergy Appreciation Day is the second Sunday in October, and the entire month is celebrated as Clergy Appreciation Month. Any member of your church would be thrilled to receive a gift as a token of your appreciation.

DadsAgree.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Register for the dad’s super discounts​

Dads Agree
1006 Cherry St SE
Grand Rapids, MI 49506
hello@dadsagree.com
(616) 777-7871
Logo